The Visa Term
Live
Visas

Court orders fresh visa decision for Gaza student with UCC scholarship

The High Court overturned a student visa refusal for Shaymaa Abudalu, a Gazan student with a UCC engineering scholarship, citing significant errors by the Department of Justice and ordering a new decision within 10 working days.

The High Court overturned a student visa refusal for Shaymaa Abudalu, a Gazan student with a UCC engineering scholarship...

The High Court has ordered Ireland's Minister for Justice to issue a fresh decision on a Palestinian student visa application within 10 working days. Justice Anthony Barr ruled on Tuesday that the Department of Justice made significant and demonstrable errors in refusing Shaymaa Abudalu's long-stay student visa in July.

The judge found the usual statutory appeal process was not a sufficient remedy, as a decision would not be reached until September 2027, too late for her to take up her college place. The court ordered the application be remitted for reconsideration, with the order stayed until Thursday following a request by the State.

Scholarship secured but visa denied

Shaymaa Abudalu, a 20-year-old from Gaza, secured a fully funded place on a four-year engineering degree programme at University College Cork. She was denied the required long-stay student visa by the Minister for Justice after receiving the scholarship. Her final school exam score was 96.7 per cent.

Evidence overlooked in refusal

The court found significant errors in the refusal process. The decision-maker failed to consider submitted evidence of Abudalu's English-language proficiency and a completed financial summary form. The refusal had cited insufficient documentation, specifically the financial form and proof of English proficiency.

The State acknowledged errors in the Department's decision-making process but argued the refusal should still stand. State representative Eoin Carolan stated Abudalu failed to provide required bank statements, which are mandatory for all study visa applicants. Abudalu accepted she did not submit bank statements, explaining her four-year degree was fully funded by UCC. Her legal team argued the bank statement requirement ignored the collapse of Gaza's banking system.

Rising refusals impact other students

Abudalu's case is the lead case in a tranche of 39 similar lawsuits taken by other Palestinian students denied visas. Lawyers hope the ruling will clarify issues for the other 38 cases. Data shows a sharp rise in Palestinian student visa refusals.

PeriodApplications ReceivedRefusals Issued
2025Not specified22
Jan-Sep 2026164115

Her application was rejected on generic grounds, including failure to provide evidence of returning home after studies, a reasoning common to all 27 refusals issued this year. Almost half of the refused applicants were from the Gaza Strip. Dozens of other Palestinian students with university places and scholarships in Ireland remain in Gaza following visa refusals.

Government announcements had suggested applications would be processed speedily and sympathetically with a compassionate approach. Lawyers stated visa-processing responsibilities had moved to the Department of Justice in Dublin, whereas previously they were handled by the Irish Embassy in Tel Aviv. An open letter signed by 12 public figures urged Taoiseach Micheál Martin to intervene for 55 Gazan students refused visas, stating they passed rigorous academic checks and provided every document available in a warzone.

Justice Barr held that Abudalu had not established a legitimate expectation that Palestinian students were exempt from standard evidence requirements. Her legal team noted the minister's lawyer claimed it was unclear her primary purpose was study and that she would return home, a reasoning applied to all rejections. Alannah Faulkner of Phoenix Law, representing Abudalu, stated the court set a timeframe for a fresh decision so she could board an evacuation flight on November 23 and begin studies at UCC. Sinéad Marmion, a partner in Phoenix Law, stated the case raised very serious concerns about the integrity of the Department's processing of Palestinian study visa applications.

Topics

#Visas

Related coverage

More from Visas